Shake Shack Secret Menu

Hey there, Shake Shack fans! Did you know that Shake Shack has a “secret menu”? That’s right—there are special food items that aren’t on the regular menu. These secret treats are fun, tasty, and a little mysterious!

Some of these items are unique twists on burgers, hot dogs, fries, and even ice cream. They let you get super creative with your order, so each meal can feel like a new adventure.

In this guide, we’re going to share what’s on the Shake Shack secret menu, plus a few easy tips on how to order these hidden treats. And if you happen to know other secret menu items that we didn’t cover, feel free to tell us! We’re always on the lookout for more tasty secrets.

What’s on Shake Shack’s Secret Menu?

Shake Shack menu has all sorts of goodies! You can think of it like a “treasure map” for people who love trying new things at their favorite restaurant. From extra saucy burgers to cheesy hot dogs and even a special ice cream sandwich, there’s a surprise for everyone. Some of these items have fun names like the “Peanut Butter & Bacon ShackBurger” or the “Smoke Shack Quad Burger.” And don’t worry if you have a favorite burger that you just want to make extra tasty—you can add pickles, onions, or more Shack Sauce to make it just the way you like it.

Ready to dig into these secret options? Keep reading to find out more about each one and how to order them like a pro!

Secret Items at Shake Shack

Shake Shack has some amazing secret items that you won’t find on the regular menu. These hidden dishes bring new twists to their classic burgers and sandwiches. Let’s explore some of these secret items and see how you can order them!

1. Peanut Butter & Bacon ShackBurger

Ever thought about mixing peanut butter with a burger? Shake Shack did, and it’s as unique as it sounds! The Peanut Butter & Bacon ShackBurger is a bold mix of creamy peanut butter and crispy bacon, paired with Shake Shack’s classic ShackBurger.

The Peanut Butter Twist: This combo was once featured on the regular menu, but due to peanut allergy concerns, it was quickly removed. However, it’s still available as a secret item if you know how to order it.
How to Order It: Just ask for a ShackBurger with bacon and request peanut butter sauce on the side. Drizzle it over your burger for an explosion of salty, savory, and nutty flavors!

Note: This one’s perfect for peanut butter fans! It might just become your new favorite burger.

2. The Smoke Shack Quad Burger

This one’s for serious burger lovers who want it all! The Smoke Shack Quad Burger isn’t just any burger—it’s a massive, four-patty masterpiece loaded with cheese and smoky goodness.

The Ultimate Indulgence: With four patties and layers of melted cheese, the Smoke Shack Quad Burger is as filling as it is delicious. But be warned, it’s packed with over 2,000 calories!
Who Should Try It: If you’re not afraid of a challenge and love a big, cheesy burger, this one’s for you. However, if you’re on a diet or want a lighter meal, you might want to skip this one.
How to Order It: Simply ask for the “Smoke Shack Quad Burger” and the Shake Shack team will serve up this towering treat.

If you love rich flavors and are up for a big meal, this burger is sure to satisfy!

3. Shackburger with Pickles & Shackburger with Onions

Sometimes, the simplest tweaks make the biggest difference. Adding pickles or onions to the classic ShackBurger is a small hack, but it brings extra flavor to each bite.

Pickles and Onions: The tangy crunch of pickles and the mild kick of onions add a new layer of flavor to the ShackBurger. Whether you like the sour taste of pickles or the savory bite of onions, these toppings make the ShackBurger even better.
How to Order It: Just ask for a “ShackBurger with pickles” or “ShackBurger with onions.” They’ll add the toppings to your burger, or you can even ask for extras on the side!

Pro Tip: Try adding both pickles and onions for double the flavor!

4. Shakeburger Cheese Dog

For hot dog lovers, the Shakeburger Cheese Dog is a must-try! This isn’t your typical hot dog; it’s split down the middle and covered in hot, gooey cheese for an extra treat.

Cheesy Goodness: Imagine biting into a hot dog oozing with melted cheese. It’s rich, savory, and perfect for when you want something different.
How to Order It: Just ask for a “Cheese Dog,” and the Shake Shack team will know what to do!

It’s a simple, cheesy twist that hot dog fans will love!

5. Shack-Cago Burger

Ever thought of turning a burger into a Chicago-style classic? With the Shack-Cago Burger, you can! By combining the toppings of the Chicago hotdog with a ShackBurger, you get a unique mix of flavors.

Build It Yourself: Start with the Chicago-style hotdog, and move the toppings (like relish, onions, pickles, cucumber, tomatoes, mustard, celery salt, and peppers) over to your ShackBurger.
Optional Cheese: Add cheese to the hotdog if you want an extra layer of flavor.

With this DIY hack, you’ll have a burger that’s part Chicago hotdog and all delicious!

6. Grilled Cheese Sandwich (with Optional Bacon)

Shake Shack does more than just burgers. Their Grilled Cheese Sandwich is a cozy, cheesy option, and you can even add crispy bacon for a little extra flavor.

Comfort in Every Bite: The Grilled Cheese Sandwich is made with gooey, melted cheese and toasted bread. It’s simple but so comforting.
How to Order It: Just ask for a Grilled Cheese Sandwich and, if you want, add bacon. If you’re feeling adventurous, ask for peanut sauce on the side for a unique, savory-sweet twist!

Perfect for when you want something warm, toasty, and cheesy.

7. Bunless Shack Burger

Another bun-free option that’s just as tasty as the original! The Bunless Shack Burger is perfect for anyone avoiding bread or cutting carbs. You still get the classic Shackburger with a juicy beef patty, cheese, and all the Shack sauce, but without the bun. Instead, you get to enjoy all the great flavors in a more carb-conscious way. Just ask for it “bunless,” and you’re all set!

8. Garden Dog

For those who prefer a veggie option or just want to try something different, the Garden Dog is a delicious choice. It’s a hotdog made from a veggie-based sausage, topped with all the fresh, crunchy veggies like lettuce, tomatoes, and pickles. It’s a great option for vegetarians or anyone looking to switch things up. Just ask for a Garden Dog, and you’ll get a tasty, plant-based twist on a classic hotdog!

9. Ice Cream Sandwich

For those with a sweet tooth, the Shake Shack Ice Cream Sandwich is a must-try dessert. This isn’t just any ice cream sandwich—it’s made with warm, toasty buns and creamy Shake Shack ice cream.

How It’s Made: Ask for toasted buns on the side and choose your favorite ice cream flavor. Then, simply place the ice cream between the buns for a deliciously gooey treat!
Why It’s Special: The warm buns add a perfect contrast to the cold, creamy ice cream, making it the ultimate dessert for any time of year.

This is a great way to turn a classic ice cream sandwich into something special!

10. Spicy Fries

If you like a little heat with your fries, the Spicy Fries are the perfect secret menu item for you. These fresh-cut fries are sprinkled with spicy seasoning, adding an extra zing to each bite.

The Perfect Kick: Shake Shack’s Spicy Fries are packed with flavor, offering a light but noticeable spicy kick. They’re perfect for those who want to spice up their snack.
How to Order It: Simply ask for “Spicy Fries” and the Shack team will prepare them for you with their special seasoning.

For those who like it spicy, these fries will take your Shack snack to the next level!

11. Topped Fries

Shake Shack’s Topped Fries are an elevated take on their classic fries. These fries come loaded with delicious toppings like cheese, Shack sauce, and more.

Loaded with Flavor: Whether you add Shack sauce, cheese, or even bacon, these fries turn into a meal on their own. They’re perfect for sharing (or keeping all to yourself!).
How to Order It: Ask for “Topped Fries” and choose your favorite toppings to customize the dish just the way you like.

If you love loaded fries, this secret menu item is a dream come true.

12. Grilled Cheese and Bacon

Sometimes, you just want a comforting, cheesy sandwich, but with an extra twist. The Grilled Cheese and Bacon sandwich adds crispy bacon to Shake Shack’s already delicious grilled cheese.

Simple Yet Perfect: The grilled cheese is made with melted cheese on toasted bread, and the addition of bacon gives it that savory crunch.
How to Order It: Just ask for a “Grilled Cheese and Bacon,” and enjoy this warm, savory treat.

When you can’t decide between a grilled cheese and bacon, why not have both?

13. Shandy

If you’re looking for something refreshing, the Shandy is the perfect drink. It’s a unique mix of beer and lemonade that creates a refreshing and tangy beverage.

A Surprising Mix: The Shandy combines the lightness of beer with the sweetness of lemonade, making it a fun drink that’s both fizzy and tangy.
How to Order It: Simply ask for a “Shandy,” and most locations will know exactly what you mean. If not, ask for beer mixed into lemonade!

It might sound unusual, but it’s a cool, refreshing drink worth trying.

14. Root Beer Float

For a classic treat, the Root Beer Float combines creamy vanilla ice cream with frosty root beer. It’s the ultimate nostalgic dessert that’s both creamy and bubbly.

How It’s Made: Root beer is poured over a scoop of vanilla ice cream to create a fizzy, creamy float. It’s like dessert and drink all in one.
Why It’s Great: The mix of cold root beer and smooth ice cream creates a delightful combination of flavors. It’s the perfect treat for a hot day or when you’re craving something sweet.

Sweet, fizzy, and creamy—this float is sure to cool you off and satisfy your sweet cravings.

15. Beer Float

The Beer Float is a twist on the classic root beer float but with a grown-up touch. This dessert uses beer instead of root beer, making it a more adult-friendly version of the float.

A Grown-Up Treat: Beer is paired with ice cream to create a fizzy, creamy float with a bit of an edge. The flavors mix for a rich, unique treat.
How to Order It: Just ask for a “Beer Float,” and they’ll serve you a scoop of ice cream topped with your choice of beer.

For those who want to mix dessert with a bit of a buzz, the Beer Float is the way to go.

Extra Shack Sauce

You can ask for extra Shack Sauce if you love the taste of it.
When picking up your order, just ask for extra sauce.
Sometimes, they give it to you for free—bonus!

The Infamous “Shandy”

A Shandy is a drink made by mixing beer with lemonade.
It’s refreshing and has a cool, unique taste.
If you want to try it, just ask for beer in your lemonade.

“Chili” Pepper Cheese Fries

Just ask for them, and they’ll make these tasty fries for you.

These fries are covered in cheese and chopped chili peppers.

The chili adds a spicy kick, and the cheese makes it creamy.

Conclusion

In conclusion, Shake Shack’s secret menu offers a fun way to enjoy some creative twists on classic favorites. From bun-less burgers to mouthwatering ice cream sandwiches, there’s something for everyone.

Don’t forget to try these items next time you’re at Shake Shack, and feel free to leave a comment about your favorite secret menu item or share any tips you have for the next diner looking to explore the hidden gems on the menu.

Table of Contents

What’s on Shake Shack’s Secret Menu?